Hong Kong’s Top Ranking for Economic Freedom Gets a Good Laugh

Published on Author taylor

The right-wing US think tank ranked Hong Kong the world’s freest economy for the 20th consecutive year last week, but many expatriates and locals in the city are taking the survey result as a bit of a joke. There are a ton of examples we could use to tell the Heritage Foundation the real story of Hong Kong’s so-called “free economy”. The government has tightened its control on many sectors, from the old-fashioned property business to broadcasting services in the digital era.

In the property business, the interests of developers, buyers and sellers have been significantly affected by the government’s new tax policies. At a recent business forum, Shan Weijian, a professor-turned-private-equity-tycoon, asked the government: “Regarding the new ‘hot policy’ on properties, does New York or London have such policies? New York and London are both financial centres [that need] to attract talent, too. Their attitude is very open.”

A few days after the Heritage Foundation released its global ranking, the Economist group’s advisory service unit for senior corporate executives issued a warning on the outlook for Hong Kong’s business. It said the city was “at serious risk of losing its position as a pivotal business centre in Asia”. Meanwhile, the mainland was becoming a standalone business region for many multinationals, the Economist survey found.

Yes, Hong Kong is still the regional headquarters of many Fortune 500 firms, but the growth trend looks weak. Pressure and competition for Hong Kong is coming not just from the north. The Heritage Foundation noted the growing challenge from Singapore. While Hong Kong’s overall score in the ranking, 90.1, rose 0.8 point year on year, Singapore’s added 1.4 points to 89.4. It seems only a matter of time before Singapore is the new king of the free market.

Further reading

2 Responses to Hong Kong’s Top Ranking for Economic Freedom Gets a Good Laugh

  1. Remember to finish by editing as “html” so you can insert <p class=”base”>. Hmmm….you had, not sure why it didn’t display.

    As to the Heritage Foundation index, well, it is right-wing but that’s irrelevant because there’s no sense they skew the data – avoid ad hominem attributions. In any case, just because Hong Kong has a government doesn’t make it a dirigiste economy; the index compares it to other places. And as to businesses locating there, isn’t the issue the cost of doing business, driven by the cost of housing (wages for workers) and of business space (office rentals)? Plus you get pollution wafting over from Shenzhen and Guangzhou [= Canton]…

  2. Fixed the p-class issue (it was inserted before the image not the paragraph). It will be interesting to see the degree to which mainland China moves towards market liberalism while Hong Kong institutes a stronger regulatory framework (hopefully one based on internalizing social costs and benefits rather than pandering to vested interests). Perhaps Hong Kong will soon be, functionally, institutionally no different from the mainland.